
A New York City Democratic Socialists choir cheered a future “when there’s no NYPD,” and Greg Gutfeld lit them up on national television for it.
Story Highlights
- The choir sang about a city with “no NYPD,” using a church-standard melody.
- The video spread in November after being posted in September and aired on Fox News.
- Verses paired anti-police lines with “free homes,” “free healthcare,” and “free Palestine”.
- The group called the song a tool for marches and “the revolution,” not a policy plan.
Viral Clip Targets the New York Police Department by Name
Video from the New York City Democratic Socialists choir shows singers repeating, “When there’s no NYPD,” set to “When the Saints Go Marching In.” Reports identify the performance as a happy, chant-like tune wishing for a day with no New York Police Department. The clip’s clear target is the police force itself, not one narrow policy rule. The language is direct and sweeping, which explains why it drew fast, loud reactions online and on television.
Coverage notes the video first posted in September and then spiked in attention the week of November 20, 2026. Fox News aired the segment on Gutfeld’s show, giving the choir’s message a larger audience. That move took the chant beyond activist circles and into the mainstream debate over public safety and order in America’s largest city. The timing matched renewed attention on crime, protests, and city budgets.
Revolution Rhetoric and a Grab Bag of “Free” Demands
Reports describe verses about “free homes,” “free healthcare,” and “free Palestine,” capped with the phrase “when the revolution comes.” The mix supports Greg Gutfeld’s take that the performance pushes a broad ideological package, not a narrow reform. The song borrowed a familiar religious melody, which made the political lyrics stand out even more. That choice invited criticism for twisting a classic tune to sell a hard-left wish list that includes removing the New York Police Department.
The choir’s own description framed the song as a tool to rally crowds. They reportedly called it a “cheat code” for getting people to sing along. They said the tune is easy to adapt for marches and picket lines. That explanation shows intent to mobilize, not to explain how public safety would work without police. It does not supply details on what would replace officers, 911 response, or investigations if the New York Police Department vanished.
What the Footage Proves—and What It Does Not
The footage and coverage confirm the anti–New York Police Department lyric and the call for a future with no city police. The record also shows the song’s use of a well-known melody and its viral spread and television exposure. The available reports do not include a platform document or plan for replacing the New York Police Department’s core duties. They also do not show a named statement from the larger Democratic Socialists organization endorsing every lyric as official policy.
Greg Gutfeld Mocks Cringeworthy DSA Choir Singing About Ending the NYPD (VIDEO) https://t.co/LQ2fzOjjRW #gatewaypundit via @gatewaypundit
— John Hartnett (@SirKnightJohn) November 21, 2026
For conservatives, the core concern is simple: public safety is not a singalong. Families need officers who answer 911, deter crime, and catch violent offenders. New York City learned hard lessons when budgets and staffing fell. Singing about “no New York Police Department” without a replacement plan drifts from protest into reckless fantasy. The right debate is how to support effective, lawful policing while holding bad actors to account—not how to wish policing out of existence.
Why This Matters Under Today’s Leadership
President Trump’s administration backs law and order nationwide. Local leaders still set police budgets and rules, though. When activist groups push “no police” slogans, city councils and mayors hear it. New York residents deserve clarity about safety, staffing, and response times before any cuts or radical experiments. Viral clips can move opinion fast, but they do not keep streets safe. Adults in charge must ground decisions in results, not rhymes.
Free Speech Allows Mockery—and Demands Accountability
Americans can sing protest songs, and commentators can mock them. Both are protected speech. Accountability begins when ideas meet real life. If activists want to end the New York Police Department, they should show how crime falls, how victims get justice, and how officers’ lifesaving work gets covered. Until then, calls for “no New York Police Department” sound like a dangerous luxury paid for by families who cannot afford failure.
Sources:
thegatewaypundit.com, newsagentdata.com, x.com, twitchy.com












